A Movie Is Fiction Portraying Real Life, Duh

Each of us has peculiar habits. How eccentric is my habit to flip cards like an ice-skating judge? In my case, where I wield my impressive powers to be a film reviewer flipping numeric cards, I shall and I must wield my authority. Sitting primly at a desk I visually share a card wearing a wry smile or taught grimace. Discerning a fine line in gradients of cinema talent is arduous, I complain silently yet my face conveys all.  

What I am asking is how in the sweet hell is that ice-skating rink number calculated? The win is always so razor thin competitive, I myself grimace at the .001 or one thousandth of a sliver quite distant from a whole number yet far and away enough to beat the prior skater and carry a gold medal home.

Imbuing creativity with a sense of political freedom, let’s skate not on thin ice but reputable criteria applied to the recent movie Animals (2026). Freedom to critique has a better chance now given how the good ol’ United States of America is returning criminal “politicians” to being accountable. Thank the almighty Washington District of Colombia political Goddess. Her witchery has restored potential for democratic power in Congressional hallways called the House AND the Senate. In these revitalized times, why not entertain an exercise in flipping numeric cards to assess a cinematic experience?

Graphic novelist Alison Bechdel establishes three basic requirements: 1) the movie must have at least two named female characters 2) these two characters must talk to each other 3) the women’s conversation must be about something other than a man. If a movie succeeds to meet these criteria, a progressive Bechdel test is achieved.

Bechdel’s comic strip Dykes to Watch Out For, published for several decades in newspapers across the US, began her inspiring artistic and political influence on lives especially LGBTQ. She has also published several Graphic Novels being iconic and motivating in my own lesbian culture specific to my life while clearly “lesbian culture” has complexity in many subculture strands, there not being a generic “lesbian culture.”

Applying the Bechdel test powerfully reflects how women’s representation often goes unnoticed. This essay strives to render invisible social dynamics visible. Good news is I won’t be wearing a wry smile or a taught grimace yet I am jazzed to start flipping numeric cards every which way. Authoritative chair is where I work from because in a returning democratic country based on capital D Democracy who in the sweet hell is in my way?  

One early workday morning, housekeeper Cecilla (Adriana Paz) takes a public bus to be at a gate where she codes in accurate numbers. Now having access to the grounds, she can go to work in Brentwood, a Los Angeles mansion district. Turning a hallway corner, she finds her employer Abigail Kimball (Kerry Washington) in the kitchen, reaching for flowers Cecilla bought much earlier this morning at an outdoor market. Although two women are calling each other’s name, the source of conversation is Cecilla’s new love interest Ramon. A few minutes into the film we have criteria to flip a first card where Animals earns one full point. Curiosity question I ask is if the movie can earn a ten on a scale of ten points. Stay tuned.   

Cecilla describes Ramon as a Capataz when he worked on a Mexico ranch. He is in LA now to take care of his son Hector. To coordinate and to lead thirty employees on a Mexican ranch farm requires adept entrepreneurial experience. In Los Angeles Ramon is scrambling to source work as an hourly gardener. Abby shows Cecilla thoughtful respect when she asks what does the word Capataz mean. When her husband Mark Kimball (Ben Affleck) hears the same word, he mumbles that the guy likely “shoots varmints” or something.

Abby’s shock at her husband’s racism is blithely shrugged away in her household’s activity flow. While the Bechdel test measures a movie’s complexity (if there is one) to portray women, the word intersection deepens recognition how race and gender prejudice exacerbate one another. Animals is never short on portraying how race, class, and gender intersect in characters’ lives as obstacles to justice. A Bechdel test and the word intersection are tools to visually recognize how characters are rendered invisible.  

A Bechdel test scene shows Abigail Kimball in her office where she works as a psychologist and a client sits opposite her on the ubiquitous therapist’s sofa. The women are immersed in Bechdel testing. First, neither woman calls the other by her name. Second the conversation is uneven given professional structures and given this, third, each woman is focusing on a man while in each other’s company. “You know you have to do your own self-work first, right?” Dr. Kimball asks. And then checks a text from her boyfriend Ron who she is having an affair with. The woman in therapy complains why she has to focus on herself.

She claims how unfair that her husband doesn’t have to be in his own self-work. Tempted I am to award this one scene all the other potential points so egregious is portraying women superficially. Patience I will apply, instead. Waving a card with two points meaning the film has now earned three points in total. For repetitive clarity, on a scale of one to ten how advanced can a movie fail the Bechdel test?

Besides these two scenes in a movie lasting one hour and forty six minutes, we don’t see two women who succeed to say each other’s name, have a conversation and one that is not focused on men in their lives. Accounts for why I am now going rogue on poetic license, wielding my authoritative card flipping any which way I care and apply the Bechdel test as I see criteria fit.

Like how else are women characters in shallow stereotype? One full point is earned when Mark and Abigail’s son Denny says to his friend Hector on Halloween night, “Let’s go bitch.” His mother says, “Denny!” And his father says, “Denny, watch your language around your mother.” And Abigail says, “Around anyone!” One point tallied for this scene showing how a boy is raised to perceive his mother too fragile for strong words only his father can hear. Now we have four points earned and advancing.

When Denny returns to his house after a kidnapping scare his parents are still frightened and also euphoric. Mark exclaims, “You fucking did great!” congratulating his son on rerouting himself to walk safely home. “Dad,” Denny says. “What?” Mark asks in disbelief that Denny is truly safe. “Language around Mom,” Denny lectures his father. Everyone has a good laugh. Reality is a young kid internalizes profanity as a strong male dynamic he and his father share. Women are weakly prepared to be around this profanity language. A full one point is the tallying card we have, my dear cinema screen watchers. Five points in total so far.

The movie’s plot shows James Bureaux (Matt Gerald) as a disgruntled older Caucasian guy. Divorce papers and an eviction notice are incentivizing his wrathful criminality. We never remotely learn why though. What we hear is him calling Mark a “selfish, racist, elitist cunt.” Another rant ends in “you fucking pussy.” Appears that sexist language surfaces in times of duress for a privileged white guy. In movies, having affinity with evil villains is infrequent, but we still want to know what motivates them. Screenwriters relying on sexist language rather than complex characterization is earning a full one point and no sliver of a .001 thousandth of a close call.

When Mark’s campaign manager Sam is speaking directly with Abigail, he attempts to placate her. She refuses to listen given Sam’s political campaign manager deceit: he convinces Mark to spend the family’s entire savings account. “You just see me as the black wife who makes your candidate even more popular,” Abigail declares. “Truthfully that makes the campaign more difficult,” Sam deadpans. She looks on shocked and Sam provides no explanation. The comment is dropped superficially into a tin pan like a surgeon removing a bullet. Ping, ping is the noise in the silent void. Animals scriptwriting gives us dialogue zingers without follow through. Cards are flipping and we have seven points earned.

Character Dale Burton (Gillian Anderson) arrives into the storyline during what Sam describes as an emergency where you need a break the glass kind of woman. In walks Dale. Screenwriters give her character a script with a few intriguing lines one explaining power when she and Abigail are reckoning with each other. Dale clarifies that “leverage is the balance between the allure of incentive and the consequence of refusal. What value can I give to get what I want? What pain can I credibly threaten?” Abigail takes in Dale’s words with a stern stare. This scene fails the Bechdel test because the dialogue focuses on eradicating a man who threatens characters’ lives.

We have another full one point etched on a card and flipping into audiences view to recognize eight points have totaled. Will a perfect ten points win a failure prize? Familiar are many movies dispatching powerful women in nefarious ways. We’ll show you who is boss, mainstream patriarchal culture says through mainstream movies being made to reflect back mainstream culture to itself. Staying away from spoiler alerts, what I can garner is enough movie storyline to distribute another full one point for how Dale meets her demise. Details kept in case you go watch the movie. Having earned nine points out of ten this far, what is next? 

When the movie closes, Gayle King appears in a scene as herself interviewing Mark Kimball, aspirational politician. His African American wife Abigail sits next to him and no conversation happens between the two women because, well, you know why—the Bechdel test. Not causal as in the test caused character blandness simply a purposeful reflection method: how are complex women rendered invisible? Takes practice to notice. Not noticing is how mainstream culture works on us. Animals earns an unwittingly ambitious 10/10 Bechdel test card flipping tally.

Say we place the movie Animals in the middle of a street. In this intersection is a center place where diverse prejudices can travel various paths slamming into the intersection’s center or one character’s life. We saw this in how Abigail reacts radically different to the word Capataz than Mark. Picturing ourselves watching the movie Animals standing in the intersection nearly all scenes portray how race, class, and gender are interweaving to prevent lives succeeding. Really is something to see.

Audre Lorde often claimed her identifiers as Black, lesbian, poet, mother, and citizen. She often built writings to explore these intersections at work concurrently in her life. Yet she probably won’t fit in this cinema conversation because in the movie is an entire absence of any LGBT content. How about if you go watch for yourself?